University of OtagoTuesday 21 February 2012, 10:56AM
Admissions to New Zealand hospitals from infectious diseases
have jumped dramatically over the last two decades according to
just published research from the University of Otago,
Wellington.
The new study in the prestigious international medical journal The
Lancet shows that hospitalisations from infectious diseases
increased by 51% over the 20 year period 1989 to 2008, accounting
for 27% of all acute hospitalisations in New Zealand between 2004
and 2008. By contrast hospitalisations from non-infectious diseases
have increased by only 7%.
Lead investigator, Associate Professor Michael Baker, says he was
'taken aback' by the size of the increase.
"What we expected to see was a steady decline in serious infectious
diseases and a rise in admissions for chronic diseases, such as
cancer and diabetes, which is the expected pattern for a developed
country."
"Instead we found infectious diseases had risen far faster than
chronic diseases. New Zealand now has the double burden of rising
rates of both infectious and chronic diseases".
This first-ever study of serious infectious diseases across an
entire country and over an extended period was based on analysis of
5 million overnight admissions to New Zealand hospitals over a
20-year period. It tracked trends across major population groups
according to age, ethnicity and socio-economic status.
It found that most categories of infectious disease have risen,
with the main contributions coming from increases in respiratory,
skin and gastrointestinal infections.
The rise in rates was not even over this period. The largest
increase in infectious diseases was in the 1990s, then some
improvement in 2001-05, followed by a more recent increase. The
rise in the 1990s coincided with a period of rapidly rising income
and wealth inequalities associated with major restructuring of the
New Zealand economy.
"All New Zealanders pay the price of rising infectious diseases.
There are those who are directly affected by these infections But
these contagious diseases affect all sectors of society. The
increased rates are adding 17,000 hospitalisations a year and tens
of millions of dollars in avoidable health care costs," Baker
says.
The research also showed that ethnic and income inequalities in
infectious diseases are large and increasing. Māori and Pacific
peoples are more than twice as likely as the European population to
be hospitalised with a serious infectious disease. And those living
in the most deprived neighbourhoods have almost three times the
risk compared with those living in the most affluent areas.
"Fundamentally what this new research reveals is that the poorest
sections of our community are bearing the brunt of an increasing
burden of infectious disease, with children and older people in
particular ending up in hospital; this is especially so for Māori
and Pacific peoples," he says.
For children under five years infectious diseases now account for
64% of acute admissions for Māori children and 68% for Pacific
children, compared with 55% for European and other children.
"Because Māori and Pacific populations tend to be over-represented
in the poorest suburbs there is a multiplier effect regarding
infectious disease risk. This has seen a 77% increase in
hospitalisations for Māori and a 112% increase for Pacific peoples
from the most deprived areas over the last two decades."
Baker says an example is rheumatic fever, which has almost
disappeared as a childhood disease in Western Europe and North
America, but is still a serious threat for Māori and Pacific
children in New Zealand, causing heart disease and early death in
adulthood.
The increased health risk for Māori and Pacific peoples, compared
with the European and other group, is much higher for infectious
than for non-infectious diseases. As a result, prevention of
infectious diseases is likely to be a particularly effective way to
reduce ethnic health inequalities in New Zealand.
In an accompanying editorial in The Lancet, Stephen Lim and Ali
Mokdad from the University of Washington commented:
"These findings challenge the epidemiological transition theory
whereby development is accompanied by a shift of health burden
towards chronic diseases and have enormous implications for health
and social policy in New Zealand. The health of indigenous people
in New Zealand has historically been poorer than the rest of the
population and these findings suggest that a rising burden of
infectious disease may be leading to a widening of this gap. Urgent
action must be taken to reverse this trend."
Co-author Professor Philippa Howden-Chapman says there is a need to
develop interventions that address major causes of poor health,
including additional strategies to reduce poverty, lower household
crowding, and improve access to immunisation and other health
services.
"Fortunately we know that it's possible to reduce these distressing
diseases - lowering household crowding is the first step The
government should be motivated to act, as prevention will save
expensive hospital costs".
The study was funded by the Ministry of Health and the Health
Research Council.
--
Detailed findings from the paper:
• Infectious diseases are the most common reason for overnight
hospitalisation in NZ (excluding child birth). They accounted for
27% of acute hospital admissions in the 2004-08 period.
• The incidence of hospitalisation for serious infectious disease
increased in absolute terms over the 20-year period
1989-2008:
• 1989-93 - annual rate 1,242 per 100,000 population (equivalent to
1.2% of the population admitted overnight for treatment of an
infectious disease each year)
• 2004-08 - annual rate 1,880 per 100,000 population (equivalent to
1.9% of the population admitted overnight for treatment of an
infectious disease each year)
• The incidence of hospitalisation for serious infectious disease
also increased in relative terms over the 20-year period
1989-2008:
• The incidence of overnight admission for infectious diseases rose
by 51% compared with non-infectious diseases which rose by 7%
• Consequently, the proportion of acute hospitalisations caused by
infectious diseases increased from 21% in 1989-93 to 27% in
2004-08
• The increasing trend observed from 1989 to 2008 appears to have
continued in 2009 and 2010. The infectious disease hospitalisation
rate in 2009 of 1,992 per 100,000 population (equivalent to 2.0% of
the population admitted overnight for treatment of an infectious
disease) was the highest reported over this period, and dropped
slightly in 2010.
• Hospitalisations for serious infectious diseases are concentrated
in children under 5 years of age followed by older adults (70+
years). Rates are relatively low in those aged 5-69 years.
• Māori are 2.2 more likely and Pacific peoples 2.4 times more
likely to be hospitalised for serious infectious diseases than the
European/Other population (based on 2004-08 data).
• Those living in the poorest neighbourhoods (deprivation scores of
9 and 10 using the NZDep index) are 2.8 times more likely to be
hospitalised than those living in the least deprived.
• Māori and Pacific ethnicity and deprivation (poverty) are
independent risk factors for serious infectious diseases. For
example, at every level of deprivation, Māori are between 58% and
85% more likely to be hospitalised than the European/Other
population.
• These ethnic 'gradients' in risk for infectious diseases are much
stepper than those for non-infectious diseases. For example, for
Māori the excess risk of infectious diseases is about twice as
large as the excess for non-infectious diseases. This finding
suggests that lowering infectious disease risk across the
population may be a particularly good way of reducing the health
gap between Māori and non-Māori.
• Ethnic and socio-economic inequalities are increasing:
• In 1989-93 Māori were 2.0 times more likely to be hospitalised
for an infectious disease than European/Other, increasing to 2.2
times more likely in 2004-08.
• In 1989-93 Pacific peoples were 1.9 times more likely to be
hospitalised than European/Other, increasing to 2.4 times more
likely in 2004-08.
• In 1989-93 the poorest 20% of the population (based on living in
the 20% most deprived neighbourhoods) were 2.4 times more likely to
be hospitalised with an infectious disease compared with the most
affluent 20% of the population (based on living in the 20% least
deprived neighbourhoods), increasing to 2.8 times more likely in
2004-08.
• Ethnic inequalities in risk have risen fastest for children less
than 5 years of age. This is particularly important as pre-school
aged children are the most vulnerable to infectious diseases based
on having the highest rates.
• In 1989-93 Māori children were 1.6 times more likely to be
hospitalised than European/Other children, increasing to 2.1 times
more likely in 2004-08.
• In 1989-93 Pacific children were 1.5 times more likely to be
hospitalised than European/Other children, increasing to 2.1 times
more likely in 2004-08.
• Poverty and being of Māori or Pacific ethnicity both contributed
to an increase in risk over the 20-year study period:
• In 1989-93 Māori in the most deprived 20% of neighbourhoods had
an annual rate of hospitalisation for serious infectious diseases
of 2,479 per 100,000 population (equivalent to 2.5% of the
population admitted overnight for treatment of an infectious
disease each year), increasing to 4,403 per 100,000 population
(equivalent to 4.4% of the population) in 2003-08. This was a 78%
increase in risk.
• In 1989-93 Pacific peoples in the most deprived 20%
neighbourhoods had an annual rate 1,953 per100,000 population
(equivalent to 2.0% of the population admitted overnight for
treatment of an infectious disease each year), increasing to 4,147
per 100,000 population (equivalent to 4.1% of the population) in
2003-08. This was a 112% increase in risk.